CONFUSION
OVER RULES OF
GOLF CHANGES

ALTERNATIVE RULES PROPOSED BY THE
AMERICAN GOLF HANDICAP ASSOCIATION

Published by : Stuart McLean - 12 January 2023

We’re seeing five key changes to the Rules of Golf for 2023, aimed we must assume towards making the game more enjoyable and fairer.

Golfers can now replace a damaged club and get free relief if a ball is moved by natural forces after being dropped, placed or replaced (as happened to Rickie Fowler on the PGA Tour where a dropped ball at rest then ran back into a water hazard). And a dropped ball can now roll closer to the hole as long as it is within a club length of where it is dropped.

One peculiar rule change though: we no longer have to ensure our correct handicap is included on a competition scorecard. More about that further on.

However, there are other “changes” to the Rules being simultaneously announced by an American body called the Golf Handicap Association which are genuinely confusing golfers worldwide because their website looks so officially plausible. And the website states the GHA “is in charge of maintaining the core rules of golf.”

Many golfers have been reacting joyously to news that the 2023 changes will include: A free drop from divots on fairways; placing your ball in bunkers if you’re in a footprint that hasn’t been raked; using alignment sticks on the course; and the COR limit on drivers being increased from .830 to .930 to gain extra distance through the spring-like effect.

It’s not fake news if you’re American and a member of GHA, because this is all seemingly permissible for the thousands who obtain handicaps from GHA.

Here in South Africa our golf clubs have rigorously applied the Rules set by the Royal & Ancient, and we abide by them, yet there’s long been a sub-culture of golfers in the United States who are happy to play by a different set of rules. They don’t entirely respect the honour system that is a cornerstone of the game.

This, after all, is a country where the mulligan is commonplace, the self-correcting Polara ball was invented, and you can purchase illegal equipment. When COR restrictions were first imposed by the USGA on titanium drivers in 1998, Callaway developed a driver, the ERC, that didn’t conform to the .830 limit.

The GHA, which believes golfers are unhappy with the current rules, have introduced some silly changes, such as allowing a maximum of 18 clubs instead of 14 (too much choice), placing in a bunker (no one would then bother to rake bunkers), alignment sticks on the course (surely that would slow down play), and allowing giant 600cc heads on drivers. Yet others are sensible for the club golfer to which they are aimed.

Dropping from divots for instance has been advocated on the pro tours. The GHA allow free relief from rocks and roots, but only if you can advance the ball. This would be helpful in avoiding injuries. Rangefinders that calculate elevation, slope and wind speed are allowed together with informational devices, on the basis that pro golfers have access to this information from their caddies. And the GHA say golfers don’t have to take a drop from knee height – they can drop the ball between knee and shoulder height.

Another rule the GHA have right is that golfers on the course can only listen to music on headphones so as not to distract others. There is nothing in the Rules of Golf to prevent golfers having speakers on their golf carts and playing music, “as long as consideration is shown to others.” That’s open to interpretation. We do know plenty of golfers who are not the most considerate of people.

THIS CHANGE ONLY HELPS LAZY, ABSENT-MINDED GOLFERS

As for the “real” Rules of Golf, I was dismayed by the decision to eliminate the penalty for a player failing to write down their handicap on the scorecard, or entering the wrong handicap. How does it help anyone but the absent-minded, the lazy golfers who can’t be bothered checking their handicap index before a round, and those who profit from others not spotting their errors? Since when was it a hardship to enter your correct handicap on a scorecard?

The R&A and USGA are clearly trying to eliminate the time-honoured practice of golfers using paper scorecards, and wish to force them into scoring on hand-held devices.

However, in SA, with all our competitions and pot-hunters, where scorecards remain popular, this presents a potential nightmare for golf club staff checking scorecards and who are already dealing with Course and Playing Handicaps on top of the handicap index.

What if golfers get in the habit of not revealing their handicaps on the scorecard? Previously they would be disqualified. Now it simply causes an inconvenience, and will delay the scoring process at clubs where members are waiting for prizegiving. And how can anyone accurately mark a scorecard with Stableford points if handicaps are not written down?

Article Search
Search for news articles
Top 100 Course News, Blog
and Feature
Recent news articles
There was a change of the guard… Read more
Mount Edgecombe Country Club is hosting two… Read more
TOP 30 GREENS IN SOUTH AFRICA 1… Read more
Houghton and Hermanus are two clubs at… Read more
Woodhill continues its phenomenal rise up the… Read more
Having a river flowing through your course… Read more
Atlantic Beach is one of those courses… Read more
Katberg, Orkney and Emfuleni are this year’s… Read more
An exciting project in Mpumalanga is the… Read more
We’re seeing five key changes to the… Read more
The Eastern Cape has been included as… Read more
Of all the great tournament venues that… Read more
The Alfred Dunhill Championship is one of… Read more
Royal Johannesburg’s newly renovated West Course was… Read more
Durban Country Club’s iconic short par-4 18th… Read more
Composite courses could become fashionable locally in… Read more
Blair Atholl is an exciting new addition… Read more
Veteran East London Golf Club member Denis Jones… Read more
How would you react if you learned… Read more
Blair Atholl has the longest stretch of… Read more
Amanzimtoti Country Club suffered the most devastation… Read more
Durban Country Club will next year be… Read more
Bryanston Country Club head teaching professional Leigh-Jane… Read more
Work has started on the refurbishment of… Read more
Golf Digest magazine in the United States… Read more
The Sunshine Tour visited 17 of SA’s… Read more
TOP 20 GREENS 1 Fancourt Links, 2… Read more
No 1-ranked Fancourt Links claimed more honours… Read more
Links courses were the big winners in… Read more
Gauteng is endowed with wonderful golf courses,… Read more
Today’s announcement of 20 courses ranked between… Read more
Anyone who has played at Plettenberg Bay… Read more
Woodhill is one of 17 courses in… Read more
Four courses – Reading, Eagle Canyon, Centurion… Read more
Two new entrants to the Top 100… Read more
Such has been the huge amount of… Read more
The new year ushered in great excitement… Read more
The 2022 Top 100 Course Rankings will… Read more
It was 30 years ago this January-February… Read more
Christiaan Burke, this year’s scoring sensation in… Read more
In recent years golfers have experienced more… Read more
Ian Leach, a doyen of golf club… Read more
They do not count as criteria when… Read more
Following the oddest year in major championship… Read more
From Plettenberg Bay in the east to… Read more
Veteran Western Province golfer Greg Woodbridge gave… Read more
In a high-profile appointment, Meyer du Toit,… Read more
Fancourt in the Garden Route is acknowledged… Read more
After an innovative, lengthy and suspenseful week… Read more
Golfers in the greater Gauteng region are… Read more
South Africa’s collection of bushveld courses are… Read more
Big positional swings are a feature of… Read more
Three of the new entrants into the… Read more
My 61-day Road Trip visiting 70 courses… Read more
Cash prizes for holes-in-one are being offered… Read more
The design of the standard golf cart… Read more
Zimbali Lakes has been an anticipated golf… Read more
Highland Gate was a popular venue for… Read more
It’s not fashionable today but there was… Read more
The Humewood links in Port Elizabeth has… Read more
A countdown has begun to the announcement… Read more
Irene Country Club elected its first female… Read more
The Top 100 Courses website has a… Read more
I’m on a road trip around South Africa aiming to complete visiting… Read more
The PGA of South Africa announced its… Read more
Pinnacle Point have done it again and… Read more
Gary Player Country Club will become the… Read more
St Francis Links has introduced a great… Read more
Big changes are taking place at South… Read more
Colin Nel at the weekend became the… Read more
ENVIRONMENTAL AWARD FOR ST FRANCIS LINKS During… Read more
The golfing members at Irene Country Club… Read more
While golf has happily resumed, with most… Read more
One of South Africa’s iconic golf courses,… Read more
GolfRSA today received the green light for… Read more
Golf courses around South Africa serve as… Read more
The golf industry will need to adapt… Read more
GolfRSA is making every effort to ensure… Read more
South African golf courses today are increasingly… Read more
PGA professional John Dickson spends most of… Read more
One of the stated 10 keys to… Read more
The national lockdown over the coronavirus has… Read more
David Melman is the Golf Manager at… Read more
Golf clubs have been issued with lengthy… Read more
There are a handful of golf courses… Read more
When the idea of a Top 100… Read more
Silver Lakes Golf & Wildlife Estate in Pretoria has been named one… Read more
Golf participation in South Africa would appear to be increasing, with Handicap… Read more
Serengeti Estates in Ekurhuleni has created one… Read more
Intimidating and challenging closing holes help create… Read more
Umhlali Country Club in Ballito on the… Read more
Erinvale Country Estate & Golf Club is… Read more
The Links at Fancourt and Leopard Creek… Read more
It’s a magical scoring barrier everywhere in… Read more
Royal Johannesburg & Kensington will make history… Read more
FIND A TOP 100 COURSE