DESIGN
DILEMMA AT
PLETT BAY CC

SAD LOSS OF HISTORIC OAK TREES ON 14TH HOLE

Published by : Stuart McLean - 02 February 2022

Anyone who has played at Plettenberg Bay CC, ranked No 44 this year and a course which has hosted the SA Senior Open the last four years, will have no difficulty recalling the distinctly odd short par-4 14th hole. This is a quirky setup if ever there was one.

Oak trees at Plett Country Club killed by borer beetle disease
View of the oak trees in their prime from the 14th green.

First of all you tee off from a mat inside the natural forest which is a feature of the beautiful back nine. No grass will grow in there. The fairway turns sharp left, and directly in front of a raised green are two enormous oak trees, so close together that their leafy canopies are touching each other.

The trick with your tee shot is to find somewhere on the far side of the fairway where you have an opening to the green. Middle of the fairway is usually stone dead. From there you need to get creative, possibly a running shot up the steep false front of the long narrow green. The green itself is a creatively challenging one, by Rob O’Friel in his 2000 redesign of the layout. A lot can go wrong with the approach. The hole would rate as one of my favourite short par 4s, even though it has often frustrated me.

However, here comes the bad news. The two oak trees, riddled I believe with borer beetle disease, were emasculated last year by tree fellers. All that remains are two trunks and protruding bare branches. They look hideous. Half the height too. Now you can easily hit a short iron over them on to the green. The Plettenberg Bay CC management and committee are unsure what to do about the future of the 14th.

Sad sight of chopped down oak trees on the 14th.

I’m glad to see they are not acting hastily about a solution. A good hole can still emerge from this because the green is a classic. And I like its positioning. The best golf designers in the country should all be consulted. A new elevated tee position might be the answer if environmental restrictions allow it.

Article Search
Search for news articles
Top 100 Course News, Blog
and Feature
Recent news articles
Blair Atholl has the longest stretch of… Read more
Bryanston Country Club head teaching professional Leigh-Jane… Read more
Amanzimtoti Country Club suffered the most devastation… Read more
Durban Country Club will next year be… Read more
Work has started on the refurbishment of… Read more
Golf Digest magazine in the United States… Read more
The Sunshine Tour visited 17 of SA’s… Read more
TOP 20 GREENS 1 Fancourt Links, 2… Read more
No 1-ranked Fancourt Links claimed more honours… Read more
Links courses were the big winners in… Read more
Gauteng is endowed with wonderful golf courses,… Read more
Today’s announcement of 20 courses ranked between… Read more
Anyone who has played at Plettenberg Bay… Read more
Woodhill is one of 17 courses in… Read more
Four courses – Reading, Eagle Canyon, Centurion… Read more
Two new entrants to the Top 100… Read more
Such has been the huge amount of… Read more
The new year ushered in great excitement… Read more
The 2022 Top 100 Course Rankings will… Read more
It was 30 years ago this January-February… Read more
Christiaan Burke, this year’s scoring sensation in… Read more
In recent years golfers have experienced more… Read more
Ian Leach, a doyen of golf club… Read more
They do not count as criteria when… Read more
Following the oddest year in major championship… Read more
From Plettenberg Bay in the east to… Read more
Veteran Western Province golfer Greg Woodbridge gave… Read more
In a high-profile appointment, Meyer du Toit,… Read more
Fancourt in the Garden Route is acknowledged… Read more
After an innovative, lengthy and suspenseful week… Read more
Golfers in the greater Gauteng region are… Read more
South Africa’s collection of bushveld courses are… Read more
Big positional swings are a feature of… Read more
Three of the new entrants into the… Read more
My 61-day Road Trip visiting 70 courses… Read more
Cash prizes for holes-in-one are being offered… Read more
The design of the standard golf cart… Read more
Zimbali Lakes has been an anticipated golf… Read more
Highland Gate was a popular venue for… Read more
It’s not fashionable today but there was… Read more
The Humewood links in Port Elizabeth has… Read more
A countdown has begun to the announcement… Read more
Irene Country Club elected its first female… Read more
The Top 100 Courses website has a… Read more
I’m on a road trip around South Africa aiming to complete visiting… Read more
The PGA of South Africa announced its… Read more
Pinnacle Point have done it again and… Read more
Gary Player Country Club will become the… Read more
St Francis Links has introduced a great… Read more
Big changes are taking place at South… Read more
FIND A TOP 100 COURSE